1231 POINSETTIA AVENUE, MLS# – O6357849

A masterful blend of Tuscan-inspired architecture and mediterranean new construction awaits in this spectacular Cape Dutch total remodel on one of College Park’s most picturesque brick-lined streets. No detail was overlooked—this home showcases high-end finishes, top-quality materials, and custom wood and metal craftsmanship throughout. It offers the beauty of old-world architecture combined with the peace of mind of present-day construction, a rare opportunity to own a true Tuscan-inspired masterpiece in the heart of College Park. This exquisite property has been meticulously maintained to preserve its pristine condition. From the moment you arrive, imagine coming home each day to your very own private villa, perfect for entertaining and everyday luxury living. Homes of this caliber are exceptionally rare and, in this neighborhood, typically sell within days. Step inside to an abundance of natural light and an impressive 22-foot ceiling, highlighted by a custom cast-iron balcony railing. Beneath your feet are oversized Italian porcelain stone tiles that set the tone for the home’s elevated aesthetic. The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, featuring Cambria quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a GE Café six-burner gas convection range, Frigidaire Professional microwave convection oven, and a Nantucket custom dark brown farm sink. Conveniently located off the kitchen is the home’s third full bathroom. The spacious family room is designed for relaxation and gathering, with ample natural light, a gas fireplace, and a 65-inch flat screen television mounted above a striking hickory mantle. Also on the main level is a versatile guest bedroom/den/office. Ascend the custom hickory staircase and feel the quality in every step, complemented by elegant iron handrails. Behind 9-foot arched doors, the master suite awaits—a true retreat featuring distressed hickory flooring, soaring 15-foot vaulted ceilings, walk-in closet, long hanging closet, coffee bar, and a spacious spa-inspired master bathroom. The upstairs guest bedroom includes an en suite bath and walk-in closet. The original balcony railing was thoughtfully preserved and offers a dramatic view over the grand entryway. Tucked discreetly behind a door in the upstairs foyer is the oversized stacking washer and dryer. For those who love to entertain, there are two incredible outdoor living spaces: relax upstairs on the master’s private deck overlooking a lush bed of ivy, or host gatherings downstairs under the large pergola in the patio, showcasing original coquina stone columns and massive cypress beams. Located in the heart of affluent College Park, just steps from Lake Ivanhoe and surrounded by million-dollar lakefront estates, this residence offers unparalleled access to the best of Orlando and Winter Park. You are minutes from the Dr. Phillips Performing Arts Center, Amway Arena, Camping World Stadium, Orlando City Soccer Stadium, Advent Health Hospital, Lake Highland Preparatory School, Rollins College, and Winter Park’s renowned Park Avenue. This exceptional College Park gem is a once-in-a-lifetime offering and will not remain on the market long. Schedule your private showing today.

Additional Details

• Elementary School: Princeton Elem
• Middle Or Junior School: College Park Middle
• High School: Edgewater High
• Architectural Style: Cottage, Custom, Other
• Baths Full: 3
• Baths Half: 0
• Modification Timestamp: February 2, 2026 at 09:00pm
• Building Area: 2385
• Cooling: Central Air
• Days on the Market: 90
• Direction Faces: West
• Directions: Form Edgewater drive, turn east on Sheridan and go to Poinsettia, take a right and home will be on your left.
• Fencing: Fenced, Masonry
• Fireplace Features: Family Room, Gas
• Flooring: Tile, Hardwood
• Foundation Details: Slab
• Furnished: Negotiable
• Heating: Natural Gas
• Laundry Features: Inside, Laundry Closet
• Levels: Two
• List Agent Email: [email protected]
• List Agent: Marie Helen Ledbetter
• List Agent Phone: 407-286-4363
• List Office: COLDWELL BANKER RESIDENTIAL RE
• List Office Phone: 407-647-1211
• Listing Terms: Cash, Conventional
• Lot Features: In County, Landscaped, Sidewalk
• MLS Area Major: 32804 - Orlando/College Park
• MLS Status: Active
• Modification Time Stamp: February 2, 2026 at 08:55pm
• Roof: Shingle
• Source System: 774230046
• Status Change Time: November 4, 2025 at 07:51pm
• View: Trees/Woods
• WaterSource: Public
• Zoning: R-1/T